Skip to Content
Ask About Consultations 717-775-7195
Top

Trying to "Win at Custody" Can Backfire: Lessons from a New Pennsylvania Superior Court Decision.

Child holding father's hand
|

When parents fight over a custody schedule, it is easy to treat the case like a contest. Who gets more overnights? Who decides the activities? Who can show the judge that the other parent is unreasonable?

A new Pennsylvania Superior Court decision is a reminder that family court does not score the case that way. In *Surma v. Surma*, No. 339 WDA 2026 (Pa. Super. Nov. 12, 2026), the court affirmed a shared-custody order from Allegheny County Family Court and left in place several terms the father had tried to change. The memorandum is marked non-precedential under Superior Court Operating Procedure 65.37, but it may be cited for its persuasive value under Pa.R.A.P. 126(b). The lessons for parents are practical: courts look at which parent is focused on the children, and evidence gathered to "win" the case can cut the other way.

What the trial court ordered

The parents already shared legal and physical custody of their two children under a 2022 order. In 2024, Father petitioned to modify the 50/50 schedule, daily video calls, and extracurricular activities, while stating that he was not asking for primary physical custody or sole legal custody. After a hearing, the trial court kept shared physical and legal custody but gave Mother sole legal custody over extracurricular activities, "[d]ue to the parties' inability to coparent in this area." It also moved most custody exchanges to school and kept daily video calls with the parent who did not have the children that day. Father's request for reconsideration produced only a limited change to vacation time. He appealed. The Superior Court, in a memorandum by Judge Olson, joined by Judges Bowes and Murray, affirmed.

The factor that mattered most: conflict, not "winning"

Pennsylvania trial courts must consider the custody factors in 23 Pa.C.S. § 5328(a), as amended, and explain their decision. The trial court called factor 2.3 (the level of cooperation and conflict between the parties, including which parent is more likely to encourage contact with the other parent) "the most salient in this inquiry."

Both parents admitted they could not co-parent effectively. Father blamed Mother. The court disagreed. It found that Father "produced no significant evidence that Mother interferes with his custodial time or is consistently unreasonable." His "exhibits and narrative," the court wrote, "expose a desire to 'win at custody' rather than to parent healthy, happy, well-adjusted" children. "And herein lies the crux of the problem": "Father's focus [is] on custody litigation rather than the well-being of [the Children]."

The findings were concrete. After one child broke an arm, went to two hospitals, and had a cast put on, Father took the child home, left her with a nanny, and went back to work "to deprive Mother of custodial time." He had threatened to pull the children from events if Mother would be there, including the first day of school if she came to take a photograph. Mother, the court found, presented as "a calm and rational person who is tired of all the litigation." She was "not without fault," and both parents had made negative comments about the other in front of the children. Even so, factor 2.3 weighed "heavily" in Mother's favor. On safety and on prioritizing the children's needs, the court favored Mother only slightly. It found the children "highly intelligent and well-adjusted" and "not in need of any therapy or treatment," but warned that "if the parties do not cease anxiety inducing behavior, that may not be the case for long."

When surveillance video and police reports backfire

Father offered a home-surveillance video that, in his view, showed Mother being unreasonable at a custody exchange. The trial court saw something else: "Father's failure to communicate and his dysregulated behavior." The Superior Court agreed that the record supported that characterization.

Father also introduced police records. Those records showed that, from May to September 2024, he contacted the police numerous times in an effort to have Mother arrested after a custody-exchange dispute over an item one of the children wanted to take with her. He asked that Mother be prosecuted for harassment, and even for calling at the appointed time for video calls. When the officers declined, he asked that the incident be documented "in case he needs it in the future." Evidence offered to prove the other parent is the problem can end up proving something different.

Split legal custody, and a petition that can open the whole order

Legal custody is the right to make major decisions for a child. Shared legal custody is common, but it is not required in every area of a child's life. Here, the court left legal custody shared overall but gave Mother sole authority over extracurricular activities. Father argued that even "high-conflict parents may still share legal custody." The Superior Court held that the trial court had considered the Section 5328(a) factors and explained its reasons, which is what the statute requires. In a footnote, the panel noted that an older four-factor test from *Wiseman v. Wall* has been "subsumed" by that analysis.

Father also argued that the court went too far because Mother never filed a counterclaim. The Superior Court rejected that due-process argument. Once a parent files a petition to modify custody, and the parties have notice that custody is at issue, the court may modify the order to serve the child's best interests. It "is not constrained to consider only the modifications sought by the petitioning party."

Moving most exchanges to school reduced Father's overnights by one night in a two-week period, and his hours in that period by an hour and a half. Father argued this "effectively" gave Mother primary physical custody. The Superior Court disagreed. "Shared physical custody" means each parent has "significant periods" of time with the child; it does not require a perfectly equal split. The trial court found the change was a matter of "practicability," and it agreed with Father's own testimony that school exchanges would be better for the children. As the Superior Court put it: "No child should be faced with this level of turmoil and police interaction before beginning their educational endeavors for the day."

Daily video calls are not a scoreboard

Father asked the court to drop the daily video calls, calling them a "recurring source of conflict." He had used software to measure their length and argued that the children spent more time talking with Mother, which, as the trial court put it, was "somehow not fair to him." The court kept the calls. It found no evidence of "nefarious action" by Mother and found, instead, that Father often ended calls early or withheld them. "The Children enjoying daily [video calls] with one parent more than the other [parent]," the court wrote, "is not a valid reason to drastically reduce the frequency of those [video] calls."

The Superior Court agreed: "Parenting is not a competition between the involved parties to see which party can garner more attention from, or more time with, the child. Rather, parenting is taking actions, regardless of personal sacrifice or appreciation received, that are in the best interest of the child." The calls, the panel explained, give children a chance to speak with the other parent and give that parent a "window into the Children's lives."

Why custody appeals are hard to win

A parent who disagrees with a custody order often wants a second court to reweigh the evidence. That is not how Pennsylvania appeals work. The Superior Court's review is broad, but it may not "nullify the fact-finding function" of the trial judge who saw and heard the witnesses. It will defer on credibility and the weight of the evidence, and it will reverse only for an abuse of discretion. That is why Father's challenges to the video, the injury testimony, the work schedules, and the co-parenting counselor's testimony all failed.

The trial court was not required to appoint a parenting coordinator either. Under Pa.R.Civ.P. 1915.11-1, a court may appoint one after a final order in cases of repeated or intractable conflict, but a coordinator "should not be appointed in every case." After three years of unsuccessful co-parent counseling with two providers, the trial court found that a coordinator "would lead to further litigation." The Superior Court found no abuse of discretion. For parents watching deadlines, an order is not "entered" for appeal purposes until the prothonotary notes that the parties were given notice under Pa.R.Civ.P. 236. That date, not the date typed on the order, usually starts the clock.

Key takeaways for Pennsylvania parents

1. Courts watch what you are fighting for. A parent focused on "winning" custody or building a litigation file can lose ground under the statutory factors, especially the conflict factor.

2. Surveillance and police involvement can cut both ways. A judge will decide what the video and the reports actually show. Asking officers to "document" an incident for later use in court can look like litigation strategy.

3. A modification petition can open more than you asked for, even if the other parent files no counterclaim. The judge may change the order in the children's best interests, including by splitting legal custody on a subject such as activities.

4. Shared physical custody does not mean a perfectly even split. Trimming a modest amount of overnight time does not automatically create a primary-custody award.

5. Video calls are for the children, not for keeping score. Measuring call length, or asking to cancel calls because the children enjoy them more with the other parent, is unlikely to persuade a court.

6. An appeal is not a new trial. Appellate judges almost always defer to the trial court's credibility findings. The strongest case is the one you present, calmly and credibly, the first time.

If you are facing a custody dispute or a petition to modify an existing order, the details of your case matter, and the statutory factors have to be applied to your family's facts. Scaringi Law represents Pennsylvania parents in custody matters. To discuss your situation, call us at 717-657-7770 to schedule a consultation.

This blog post is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The decision discussed is a non-precedential memorandum of the Pennsylvania Superior Court.

Categories: