Arrested? Here are five tips to keep a bad situation from getting much worse

By Scaringi Law

Many defendants would have beaten charges and walked free if they hadn’t attempted to outthink police or prosecutors. Making erroneous statements, agreeing to searches, playing fast and loose with facts, and especially posting incriminating information to social media can make the difference between being free and being behind bars.

Here are five ways criminal suspects unintentionally incriminate themselves – and how to avoid these mistakes.

1. Shut the front door!
Don’t discuss potential criminal activity with anyone, including friends, family and even lovers. Such information becomes leverage. Information about a crime can help someone save their own neck, or be used to even a score, especially for ex-girlfriends.

  • Scaringi Tip: While this kind of hearsay may not hold up in court, it is permissible in obtaining search warrants, which in turn, often turn up hard evidence that ultimately convicts suspects. So, in the most basic of terms, keep your mouth shut.

2. Facebook is law enforcement’s best friend

Our compulsion to post, tweet, and live-stream on social media does no exclude criminals, and police and prosecutors know this all too well. That’s why a suspect’s social media footprint is often among the first things scrutinized in building a case.

Hard as it is to believe, some defendants have enthusiastically posted pictures of illegal drugs and weapons or boasted about criminal activity online. Obviously, this didn’t help them in court.

  • Scaringi Tip: If you’re sure you erased something, it still exists on a server. All it takes is a savvy prosecutor with a subpoena to recover anything posted on social media, especially incriminating posts.
  • Scaringi Bonus Tip: Beware of who you “friend” on social media; it might just be a law enforcement official in sheep’s clothing. Posing as prostitutes, drug buyers and even underage children interested in sex, are classic ways for cops to entice suspects.

3. Blindly consenting to searches

Many criminal cases, especially involving drugs, begin with a routine traffic stop for burned-out taillight. Technically, the officer should only look in your vehicle for what is in plain view. But many cops will politely ask for consent to fully search the vehicle.

Inexplicably, many suspects consent to these vehicle searches – even if they know there are drugs, cash or weapons to be found. They assume they have no other choice.

Actually, they do have a choice. If a police officer is asking for your consent, this means they lacks probable cause to conduct a search. Just say “No, I do not consent to your search”.

If the officer threatens to get a search warrant, tell them to go right ahead. Often, the officer’s statement is a “tactic”.

  • Scaringi Tip: It is perfectly legal for a police officer to lie to an individual in the pursuit of justice. Often, they trick suspects into consenting to a search by threatening to obtain a search warrant. Call their bluff every time.

4. Explaining is just as good as confessing

Once a police officer suspects a person of a crime, they must issue the Miranda warning. However, the “right to remain silent” begins the very moment an officer attempts to question you about a crime, which can be long before you’re read your rights. If you’ve had any involvement in a potential crime, at all, remain silent.

Many defendants unsuccessfully attempt to explain their way out of a situation and make matters worse for themselves.

Police and prosecutors love talkative suspects. The more you talk, the more likely you are to disclose evidence or change your story, which is considered lying to the police.

  • Scaringi Tip: Police cannot testify that a person refused to make a statement. Everyone has the right to remain silent under the Fifth Amendment, and no inference of guilt can be drawn from keeping quiet. Lesson learned? Shhh!

5. Non-smokers’ sense of smell is much better than a smokers’ sense of smell.

Laws are being liberalized as marijuana moves closer to decriminalization, but we aren’t there yet. If you are caught smoking a joint while driving – or even if you or your vehicle smells of pot – you have just handed police probable cause to search your person and your vehicle.

  • Scaringi Tip: Don’t smoke marijuana in your car. Don’t let anyone else light up in your car either. Even the slightest hint of that telltale odor could result in your freedom going up in smoke.

Should you have any interaction with law enforcement regarding a criminal matter, don’t say or do anything – just call your criminal defense attorney, and if you don’t have one, call Scaringi Law at 717-775-7195. Our experienced attorneys are ready whenever you need us.


    • Please enter your first name.
    • Please enter your last name.
    • This isn't a valid phone number.
      Please enter your phone number.
    • This number is my:
    • Please make a selection.
    • This isn't a valid email address.
      Please enter your email address.
    • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
Put Us On Your Side